1962 Margie Hawthorn
1963 none
1964 Betty June Cammer
1965 Jeanne Smith
1966 Cindy Newberger
1967 Audrey Metti
1968 Carol Rosenkranz
1969 Laura McDonald
1970 Sheree Kindinger
1971 Patricia Houston
1972    Joanne Droeske
1973 April Clawson
1974 Mary Lou Fackler
1975 Janet Warren
1976 Norma Mees
1977 Vicki Sayer
1978 Mary Beth Campbell
1979 Sharri Mercer
1980 Tracey Redding
1981 Dawn Arnol

1982 Jeanette Pagels
1983 Dawn Beck

1984 Susan Durda

1985 Tammy Oglesbee

1986 Katrina Clary

1987 LuAnn Carey

1988 Katie Kavanagh

1989 Denny Hainley
1990 Kimberly Kaye Taylor 
1991 Jodi Stautihar
1992 Cynthia Brook
1993 Sharon Buzon
1994 Shannon Gibson
1995 Molly Lipstreu
1996 Kimberly Mathis
1997 Jaclyn Novak
1998 Stephanie Dunderman
1999 Jessica Hobeck 
2000 Lindsey Burbank
2001 Megan Mihocik
2002 Stephanie Brigle

2003 Andrea Hernandez

2004 Jennifer Bowen

2005 Megan Hunt

2006 Brenna Stein

2007 Kaitlyn Wielichowski

2008 Raven Butkowski   

2009 Paige Reed

2010 Heather Andrews

2011 Caylin Wilhelm